In an interview with CNBC-TV18, Tarun Bhatia, Director - Capital Markets, CRISIL Research, speaks about various mutual funds schemes and ULIP.
Below is a verbatim transcript. Also watch the accompanying video.
Q: I have taken one LIC plan, which is a moneyback plan and now I want to do some more investment, I want to know which plan will give me some benefit after fifty years, shall I go for ULIP (Unit Linked Insurance Plan) or mutual fund?
A: I think looking at the age profile, I would suggest that you should look at investing in large-cap mutual funds and balanced mutual funds, which give good long-term returns and there are good options out there in terms of investment. There is Reliance Growth Fund, which has been a consistent performer, there is HDFC Top 200 on the large-cap side and there are HDFC Prudence, Reliance Regular Savings, which gave give long-term returns.
Specifically to the question of mutual funds versus ULIPs, especially you have a LIC moneyback policy, I would say that the two products are very different and you need to look at the longevity. If you are looking purely from an investment point of view, I would suggest mutual fund is a good route. But if you want to look at insurance and if you have a more than ten year timeframe, then you could look at some good ULIP options.
The other thing that you could look at is given you are just 28 and you have long-term retirement planning in your mind, there are good MIP schemes, which are out there. There is an HDFC, HSBC and Reliance MIP schemes, which are very good, offers strong returns, ranked consistently one by CRISIL, which are more a retirement planning to which you could explore.
Q: I want to start SIP (systematic investment plan) with IDFC Premier Equity Plan A and ICICI Pru Discovery Fund, can you guide me on this? I am an investor and investing in Reliance Natural Resource Fund and Tata Infrastructure Fund and I am putting in Rs 1000 each.
A: I think the portfolio has too many schemes currently and it would be advisable to consolidate at this point of time. Couple of investments seem to be in equity linked saving schemes so that’s more from tax purpose. But of what you have enquired I think ICICI Pru Discovery Fund is a good option, it is fairly consistent performing scheme, has been ranked as CRISIL rank one on a regular basis.
The other option that you have indicated of the IDFC Equity Fund, I think there are some concerns on the returns over the past 12 months. Also looking at the portfolio, I would advice that large part of investment is in diversified schemes, which are relatively higher risks. You could consolidate your portfolio and maybe move part of your investments into large-cap schemes like Birla Frontline as well as Fidelity Growth, which offer good long-term returns and are again ranked one on risk return by CRISIL.